Akademischer verlag,1993 phd thesis, ludwigmaximilianuniversitiy munchen. Following this vein, the paper attempts at meshing together the material. This highly original study demonstrates how methods of social analysis can be applied to the individual, while remaining entirely distinct from psychology and other perspectives on the person. This article seeks to bring together two conceptsarjun appadurais trajectories and annette weiner s inalienable possessions to examine how objects come to express particular forms of sacredness. Th oct 8 annette weiner, introduction, inalienable possessions.
These inalienable possessions, in the words of annette weiner, help reconstruct the past through the supplement of oral traditions. This article explores precipitating events, emotions, and decisions associated with older consumers disposition of special possessions. An objects position on the spectrum can change with context, of course, and the reformation is a prime case in which. Click download or read online button to get inalienable possessions book now. In the other kula areas of the massim, kula activity provides a context for chiefly authority where actual ranking and chiefs do not exist. Inalienable possessions the paradox of keepingwhile giving 1st edition by annette b. Students may choose one out of two kinds of written assignments in consultation with the professor. Maurice godelier has further elaborated on annette weiner s ideas on inalienable possessions in the enigma of the gift. For the linguistic term, see inalienable possession. She was known for her ethnographic work in the trobriand islands and her development of the concept of inalienable wealth in social anthropological theory. Inalienable possessions wikimili, the free encyclopedia. View the article pdf and any associated supplements and figures for a period of 48 hours. Easily share your publications and get them in front of issuus.
First, to reexamine exchange in a range of societies without the formal establishment of ranking and hierarchy, from foraging groups to egalitarian and bigman societies, and to show how ownership of inalienable possessions still generates difference that establishes a degree of political autonomy for women and men. Issuu is a digital publishing platform that makes it simple to publish magazines, catalogs, newspapers, books, and more online. Comparative analysis of gift exchange among a pentecostal christian denomination and an indigenous religious tradition in ileife, nigeria ntributor. Ecuador seeks to transform old notions of economics and the concept of value. An anthropological approach, edited by caroline humphrey and stephen hughjones, oaeoeo. Weiner 1985 weiner, 1992weiner, 1994 makes a similar distinction between alienable and inalienable possessions, which differ in the degree to which they are circulated.
The role of social valuables in establishing and defeating hierarchies in prestate societies is explored through the use of annette weiner s concept of inalienable possessions. Focusing on oceania societies from polynesia to papua new guinea and including australian aborigine groups, annette weiner investigates the category of possessions that must not be given or. In inalienable possessions, annette weiner 1992 focuses on the paradox of keepingwhilegiving rather than the norm of reciprocity as the central issue of social life, drawing heavily on. Analogous color combinations cool winter color and style guide 11 jennifer thoden an analogous color combination is a much calmer color combo compared to a.
Inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while giving download inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while giving ebook pdf or read online books in pdf, epub, and mobi format. Weiner paperback university of california press economic anthropology giving property. Archaeological biological cultural linguistic social. Pdf maya polychrome vessels as inalienable possessions. Mauss view on sacrifice was also controversial at the time. Drawing on marcel mausss notions of inalienable wealth, i enter the debates surrounding the meaning of the maori hau, the spirit embedded in persons and things.
She was best known for her work on the role of women in the trobriand islands of papua, new guinea, which challenged the. Download inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while giving ebook free in pdf and epub format. Findings are based on analyses of semistructured interviews with 80 older consumers, complemented by depth interviews with seven informants. Weiner 1992 has developed the concept of inalienable possessions to explain how the circulation of particular objects among generations play a vital role in the construction and recreation of collective identities, a process that makes these objects intrinsic to the identities of their possessors. Every class, i will call on two students to read their questions, by way of opening discussion. Social norms and customs govern gifting in a gift culture, gifts are not given in an explicit exchange of goods or services for money, or some other commodity or service. Economists have often shunned the idea of pondering exactly why people want goods. Click download or read online button to inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while giving book pdf for free now. Annette weiner inalienable possessions pdf inalienable possessionstests anthropologys traditional assumptions about kinship, annette b.
Annette b weiner inalienable possessions tests anthropologys traditional assumptions about kinship, economics, power, and gender in an exciting challenge to accepted theories of reciprocity and marriage exchange. Available formats pdf please select a format to send. Apr 17, 2019 weiner 1992, 6 draws on fieldwork on the trobriand islands, testing malinowskis earlier theories on gift exchange, and theorizes the paradox of keepingwhilegiving. What constitutes this demise need not be the loss of the carrying materiality. Focusing on oceania societies from polynesia to papua new guinea and including australian aborigine groups, annette weiner investigates the category of possessions that must not be given or, if. This seminar provides an overview of theory and practice in sociocultural anthropology. This contrasts with a barter economy or a market economy, where goods and services are primarily exchanged for value received. Copyright 2015 by jennifer thoden all rights reserved.
Weiner annette s reprints on editorships and correspondence on editorships. Auswertung eines sakraltextes zur manarungzeremonie beim totenfest. In this chapter, i use annette weiner s concept of inalienable possessions to extend analysis of late classicperiod polychromes beyond the tenets of prestige goods to. Pdf inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while. Older consumers disposition of special possessions journal. A gift economy, gift culture, or gift exchange is a mode of exchange where valuables are not traded or sold, but rather given without an explicit agreement for immediate or future rewards.
Anthropologist annette weiner refers to these types of objects as inalienable possessions and to the process as keeping while giving. A fascinating aspect of frances berdans new text, aztec archaeology and ethnohistory 2014, is the section in chapter 8 on warrior regalia as inalienable possessions. Weiner 19331997 was a prominent anthropologist and dean of the graduate school of arts and science at new york university from 19831991. Inalienable possessions the paradox of keepin by daniel. The paradox of keepingwhilegiving is a book by anthropologist annette weiner. This is an original point of view that will have real effects on the direction of future fieldwork and comparative analysis. Focusing on oceania societies from polynesia to papua new guinea and including australian aborigine groups, annette weiner investigates the category of possessions that must not be given or, if they. Save up to 80% by choosing the etextbook option for isbn. Representations of merit and emptiness in medieval chinese buddhism. Use features like bookmarks, note taking and highlighting while reading inalienable possessions. Informed by annette weiner s arguments in inalienable possessions, this thesis seeks to explore how the history and heritag e o f nicodemus, kansas is reproduced my research explores weiner s analyses through the lens of the nicodemus community and investigates the ways that women have been integral to the survival of th e nicodemus community. The sacred and the museum repatriation and the trajectories of inalienable possessions.
The statement the canal was finished from brookv ille to lawrenceburg in 1839 is confirmed in the engineers report of that year. Other inalienable possessions, whether material objects, landed property, ancestral myths, or sacred knowledge, bestow social identity and rank as well. In addition, giftgiving plays an important role in the cultural development of how social and business relations evolve in posxessions economies such as in the case of the chinese. Download pdf israelsinalienablepossesions free online.
Download pdf inalienable possessions the paradox of. This site is like a library, use search box in the widget to get ebook that you want. Read inalienable possessions the paradox of keeping while giving online, read in mobile or kindle. A more radical view was introduced in annette weiners. For each exam, students are required to respond to one out of a choice of two essay questions. This topic is explored by berdan in a rich discussion that merges annette weiner s framework with berdans own exhaustive knowledge of written and pictorial manuscript sources on the aztecs. Debt and economic renewal in the ancient near east, edited by m. Inalienable possessions tests anthropologys traditional assumptions about kinship, economics, power, and gender in an exciting challenge to accepted theories of reciprocity and marriage exchange. From old and recent classics, such as mausss the gift and graebers debt, to cutting edge provocations of economic common sense, such as weinners inalienable possessions and jane guyers marginal gains, economic anthropology has been a driving force in shaping broader theoretical debates within cultural anthropology and economics proper. Godelier contends that weiner refocuses attention on the role of women in constructing and legitimizing power. But in addition to this type of inalienable possession, the anthropologist annette weiner in her seminal study also drew attention to treasures entirely excluded from gift exchange that were integral to lineages and institutions identity and power. Weiner was a professor of anthropology and dean of the graduate school of arts at new york university, and served as president of the american anthropological association.
Kinship, citizenship, and belonging harvard university. Weiner provides not only a new perspective on social and natural reproduction but also a framework through which to compare societies. Anthropology is usually associated with the study of society, but the anthropologist must also understand people as individuals. Warior regalia and questions of inalienable possessions in. Weiner inalienable possessions tests anthropologys traditional assumptions about kinship, economics, power, and gender in an exciting challenge to accepted theories of reciprocity and marriage exchange. Economic anthropology anth 3500 5500 smoki musaraj.
Dec 15, 2010 petroleum and its worth are being reevaluated in ecuador today. Rels 440 religion and economic systems university of calgary. Anthropology 1988 kinship, citizenship, and belonging 2 written assignments 60%. Inalienable possessionstests anthropologys traditional assumptions about kinship, economics, power, and gender in an exciting challenge to accepted theories of reciprocity and marriage exchange. Calling attention to their presence in western history, weiner points out that her formulations are not limited to oceania. Annette weiner broadened the application of the category of property outside the european context with her book inalienable possessions. Read download inalienable possessions pdf pdf download. I examine the implications of such wealth through an analysis of new zealand maori valued objects, notably, woven cloaks and nephrite weapons and ornaments. Anthropology 1988 kinship, citizenship, and belonging 2 class. Weiner and publisher university of california press. Conesations an online journal of the center for the study of.
In addition, giftgiving plays an important role in the cultural development of how social and business relations evolve in. The paradox of keepingwhile giving kindle edition by weiner, annette b download it once and read it on your kindle device, pc, phones or tablets. Correspondence and bibliography about trobriand islands. These aspects are, of course, at the heart of the gift, as demonstrated in books such as annette weiner s 1992 inalienable possessions. A gift economy or gift culture is a mode of exchange where valuables are not traded or sold, but rather given without an explicit agreement for immediate or future rewards. Focusing on oceania societies from polynesia to papua new guinea and including australian aborigine groups, annette weiner investigates the category of possessions that mustnotbe. Weiner went on to show how henry maines distinction between moveable and immovable property posited the category of immovable that is, inalienable property as the greatest impediment to the free circulation of objectsthe ultimate goal of an emergent commodity economy. Inalienable possessions download ebook pdf, epub, tuebl. Bronislaw malinowski, argonauts of the western pacific long grove, illinois. Comparative analysis of gift exchange among a pentecostal.
20 1324 295 254 875 449 479 1044 1140 463 728 1189 193 309 1197 964 410 1374 1024 473 558 1095 461 590 437 1250 1538 442 1545 1381 18 1194 369 450 1223 582 1245 909 110